Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Public Law, Faculty of Law and Social Sciences, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran

2 Ph.D Student, Public Law, Faculty of Law and Social Sciences, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran

Abstract

Introduction

Hegel is a philosopher who studies the concept of the state with his multifaceted philosophy and his special methodology. On one hand, he criticizes the views of different schools of thought about this concept and believes that the government is not a mechanism to maintain peace, enforce rights, or promote benefits beyond its own existence, and only in this capacity can it be recognized by everyone as a right. On the other hand, in his theory, the divine and intrinsically purposive government is trying to incorporate all the desirable features of these schools, despite all these criticisms. notwithstanding this paradox, this research, whose sources have been collected through the library research method and descriptive-analytical study, aims to prove the hypothesis that the Hegelian state emerges from within the traditional liberal and democratic state-building philosophies in a special and distinct way. It is trying to answer the question “What are the characteristics of the ideal state in Hegel's view, In a practical look at the political philosophy of the state?”, The results show, while proving the hypothesis; that contrary to the extreme collectivism of Rousseau and the abstract individualism of Lockean liberalism, Hegel's state is ‘a reasonable and inevitable institution of society that everyone must recognize its by force and accept its obedience’.

Research Question(s)

What are the characteristics of the ideal state in Hegel's view?

Literature Review

Several research papers have been published Related to the subject of the research, including; Zahra Vashqani Farahani's thesis titled: "State Theory in Hegel's Political Philosophy" published by the Faculty of Literature and Humanities of the Islamic Azad University (Central Tehran Branch), as well as an article titled "The Importance of Hegelian Separation, State and Civil Society" written by Azim Rahin, Prepared and published in No. (1.2) of Social Sciences Quarterly. However, the distinct feature of this research is the examination of Hegel's paradigmatic view of the government, which is in many ways against or in favor of democracy and liberalism.

Methodology

Considering that research in most humanities disciplines is mainly focused on theoretical solutions, the present study has used a library research method to collect the desired data and examines the data with a descriptive-analytical method.

Conclusion

Hegel's philosophy, methodology, and valuable critiques present an outlook that thinks about modernity, instead of being oriented towards the Enlightenment era of his time. Because, basically, from Hegel's point of view, modernity is a bridge in the evolution of the soul towards freedom, and in this way, the self-awareness of the soul is the most important characteristic of the new era. In summary, for the purposes of this research and its main question, what is certain is that Hegel rejects the political theory of social contract that philosophers such as Locke and Rousseau established and views them as inefficient abstract concepts and, by rejecting the abstract idealism of "Reason" and the empiricism of "History" as an independent and durable ground for authority, established a dialectical relationship between reason and history and thereby resolved some of the contradictions raised in the state's founding phase. He also, based the political right on having an independent nature from the state and supports the concept of political right where it maintains its idealistic aspect, but is based on a certain historical era. On the other hand, even though Hegel criticizes the extreme collectivism of Rousseau and the abstract individualism of Lockean liberalism, his divine and intrinsically purposive government tries to incorporate all the desirable features of these schools and support them. Hegel's goal was to achieve the desired political power system for Germany, and so in this way, he presented his government specially and distinctly from the democratic and liberal state-building philosophies of his time.
But what are the characteristics of Hegel's ideal government? The key to understanding this question lies in the ideal concept of political right in Hegel's belief and his opinion about the inherent rationality of the state. From Hegel's point of view, the state is the manifestation of realized freedom and the perfect ethical life. Therefore, the state is an ethical soul that emerges in the form of an essential will by becoming more transparent and definite. Therefore, the state is nothing but "the action of the spirit in the world" realized in a self-conscious form. But since the soul in Hegel's philosophy has an absolute, and even divine essence, according to Hegel's definition, the state is God's will in the world. Such a government is not a responsible or parliamentary government, and this was at a time when the belief in a responsible government was considered the most important feature of 19th-century liberalism. Overall, by studying the philosophy of rights that Hegel talks about, it cannot be said that he does not explicitly accept responsible government, nor can it be said that he explicitly rejected such a government. 

Keywords

Main Subjects

Books
- Bizer, Frederick, Hegel, Translated by Seyed Masoud Hosseini (Tehran: Qaqnoos Publishing House, 2018).
-  Foroughi, Mohammad Ali, The Path of Wisdom in Europe, Second Edition (Tehran: Hermes Publishing, 2008).
- Franco, Paul, et al., Hegel's Critique of Liberalism, Translated by Khat Mamtad Andisheh Institute, (Tehran: Amirkabir Publications, 2012).
- Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich, Elements of the Philosophy of Right or a Summary of Natural Law and Political Science, Translated Mehbod Irani-Talab (Tehran: Parvin Publications, 1999).
- Jahanbeglu, Ramin, Hegel and Modern Politics, Second Edition (Tehran: Hermes Publishing House, 1379).
- Katouzian, Nasser, Basics of Public Law, Second Edition (Tehran: Mezan Publishing House, 2003).
- Katouzian, Nasser, Philosophy of Law, 4th Edition (Tehran: Sohami Publishing Company, 2005).
- Kelly, John, A Brief History of Legal Theory in the West, Second Edition, Translated by Mohammad Rasakh (Tehran: Nei Publishing House, 2018). [In Persian]- Laughlin, Martin, Basics of Public Law in the West, Translated by Mohammad Moqtader (Tehran: Majid Publications, 2014).
- Locke, John, Two Treatises on Governance, Translated by Farshad Shariat (Tehran: Negah Mazares, 2012).
- Naqibzadeh, Ahmad, An Introduction to Political Sociology (Tehran: Samet Publishing, 2014).
-  Plamenatz, John, Commentary and Critique on Hegel's Social and Political Philosophy, 7th Edition, Translated by Hossein Bashirieh (Tehran: Neshar Nei, 2019).
- Rose, David, A Guide to Reading the Elements of Hegel's Philosophy of Right (Tehran: Humanities Translator, 2016).
- Rousseau, Jean-Jacques, Social Contract, Translated by Morteza Kalantarian (Tehran: Nesharagah, 1379).
- Shumin, Gerar & et al., In the Context of the Text of the Social Contract, Translated by Morteza Kalantarian (Tehran: Nash Aghah, 1379).
-  Spector, Selin, Power and Sovereignty in the History of Western Thought, Translated  by Abbas Bagheri (Tehran: Ney Publishing, 2012).
- Taylor, Charles, Hegel and the Modern Society, Translated by Manouchehr Haghighi Rad (Tehran: Nash-e-Karzan, 1392).
- Vincent, Andrew, State Theories, 6th Edition, Translated Hossein Bashirieh (Tehran: Ney Publishing, 2007).
Articles
- Ahmadvand, Shoja, “Hegel’s Political Philosophy and Modernity”, Law and Politics Research Quarterly, No. 23, (2016).
 - Sabze-ai, Mohammad Taqi, “Civil Society as a Social Contract: A Comparative Analysis of the Thoughts of Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau”, Law and Politics Research Quarterly, No. 22, (2016). 
- Kamali-Goki, Mohammad & Zamani-Rad, Hojjat, “The Nature of the State and the Foundations of Its Establishment in the Political Philosophy of Hobbes and Locke in a Paradigmatic Novel”, Political Science Quarterly, No. 34, (2014). 
- Moradkhani, Ali & Shahbazi, Avisa, “Hegel and Political Economy, Basic Western Studies”, Research Center for Humanities and Cultural Studies, No. 1, (2019).
- Naqvi, Gholamreza, “Metaphysics and Politics: Distinguishing Civil Society and State in Hegel’s Political Philosophy”, Azad Karaj University Political Science Quarterly, No. 8, (2008).
- Wood, Alan, “Ethics from the Perspective of Hegel”, Translated by Mehdi Soltani Ghazar, Allameh Quarterly, No. 12, (2008).