Document Type : Research Paper
Author
PhD student in International Law, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
1. Introduction
In recent years, there has been a growing trend in the “North and South” dialectics in all fields. International law is no exception to this rule. Recently, in international law studies, in particular, in philosophical discourses and historical development research regarding the origin and the basis of international law obligations, efforts have been made by new scholars to spread the Eastern approach to international law. As these thoughts normally emerge from the less developed and colonial countries, it is called the “Third-World Approach to International Law (TWAIL)”. This approach is rooted in the critical legal studies movement in international law. By taking the Asian perspective into account and also, the evolution of the history of Asian civilizations, this approach attempts to address the inauspicious phenomenon of colonialism in undeveloped or less developed countries, and thereby, decenter Europe as the origin of international law.
From 1996 to 2020, we have been facing a significant increase in studies related to this third-world approach to international law, which depicts the possible emergence of a renaissance period in this field of study. Although its initial consistent rise happened between 1998 and 2012, the volume of scientific content production in this approach gradually increased. In fact, this approach points us to a re-examination of the historical evolution of international law. As mentioned, the researchers and experts of this approach are actively present in the world of international law and this approach will undoubtedly impact their opinions and activities.
Methodology
Furthermore, the third-world approaches to international law have rooted in different areas, but naturally, they have become more prominent in some categories of international law, in terms of studying the methodology and the historical background of international law that were mentioned earlier.
The third-world approach functions in two ways: first, it challenges the radicalized power and the hierarchy of international institutions and norms, and second, it examines the past and the present foundations of colonies and imperial structures of international law. Many of the insights created by the critical approach have been important and useful for the supporters of the third-world approach to international law. So, this approach will analyze the current issues of international law and human rights in a critical discourse. Although there is a fear of division and conflict in such approaches, they create more awareness and increase the debate between different nations on the subject which leads to the universality of international law. It is worth mentioning that Marty Koskenniemi and David Kennedy are
among the most famous experts in this field of study and have written many articles about this approach.
Conclusion
In conclusion, it seems that the critical and bold approach to international law through the lens of the so-called third-world countries analyzes the deep-rooted inequalities in the international community. The synergy between the critical approach and the third-world approach has expanded the content of international law norms and has created new discourses in international law. Based on the writings of the experts with the third-world approach to international law, it seems that in the past and especially in recent centuries, through the flawed phenomenon of exploitation and colonialism (both in its traditional and modern forms), the powerful countries of the world have seriously damaged the trust of other countries regarding international decisions and regulations concerning third-world countries and especially Asian countries. Thus, actions should be taken to rebuild that trust. It is possible to change the view of third-world countries to powerful countries in international relations. But the emergence of other powerful governments and Asian actors, especially those countries that have a significant impact on the international economy and, as a result, are noticeably influential on politics and international relations, can lead to a redefinition of many concepts in the modern world.
Finally, it seems that, regarding the true goals and ideals of international law, the presence of “North and South” views in all areas related to international law have led to different political sides and the current international order. challenges exist at all levels, but the examination and analysis of such multi-dimensional approaches will lead to the expansion of the discourse and exchange of opinions between different nations and will raise awareness and respect for
different cultural systems among them, which finally, contributes to the universality of international law.
Keywords
- Philosophical Schools
- Criticism
- Critical Approach
- Critical Legal Studies
- Third-World Approaches to International Law
Main Subjects
Books
- Henkin, Louis, How Nations Behave: Law and Foreign Policy (USA: Columbia University Press, 1979).
- Schweickart, David, A Democratic Theory of Economic Exploitation Dialectically Developed, Theory, Power, and Human Emancipation: Dimensions of Radical Philosophy, ed. Roger Gottlieb (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1993).
- Xue, Hanqin, Chinese Contemporary Perspectives on International Law: History, Culture and International Law (USA: Brill Nijhoff, 2012).
Articles
- Abbasi, Majid, Kiani, Ali Akbar, “A Survey on Globalization and its Cultural Impacts”, Strategic Studies of public Policy Journal, Volume 3, Issue 9 - Serial Number 9, (2013). [In Persian]
- Amir Abbas, Amirshekari, “The Impact of Critical Legal Studies (CLS) on the Evolution of the Theoretical Reflections of Legal Scholarship”, Public Law Studies Quarterly, Volume 46, Issue 3, (2011), 679-693. [In Persian]
- Anand, R.P, “The Formation of International Organizations and India: A Historical Study”, Leiden Journal of International Law, Vol. 23, No. 1, (2010).
- Anghie, Antony, “The Evolution of International Law: Colonial and Postcolonial Realities”, Third World Q. 739, Vol. 27, No. 5, )2006(.
- Anghie, Antony, “TWAIL: Past and Future”, International Community Law Review, Vol. 27, No. 5, (2008).
- Appiagyei-Atua, Kwadwo, “Ethical Dimensions of Third-World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL): A Critical Review”, African Journal of Legal Studies, Brill Nijhoff, Vol. 8, (2015).
- Askary, Pouria, Darounparvar, Amir, “Studying the Critical Thoughts of the New Stream School in International Law”, International Law Review, Volume 38, Issue 64 - Serial Number 64, (2021). [In Persian]
- Beckett, Jason A, “Rebel Without a Cause? Martti Koskenniemi and the Critical Legal Project”, German Law Journal, Published online by Cambridge University Press, 7, No. 12, (2019).
- Berman, Nathaniel, “Passion and Ambivalence: Colonialism, Nationalism and International Law”, Brill Nijhoff, Legal History Library, Volume 6/3, (2012).
- Buchanan, Ruth, “Writing Resistance into International Law”, International Community Law Review, Vol. 10, )2008(.
- Carty, Anthony, “Critical International Law: Recent Trends in the Theory of International Law”, 2 EUR. J. INT’L L. 66, (1991).
- Cassese, Antonio, “Self-Determination of People: A Legal Reappraisal”, International Journal on Minority and Group Rights (Hersh Lauterpacht Memorial Lectures), Vol. 9, No. 3 (2002).
- Chinedu Okafor, Obiora, “Critical Third World Approach to International Law (TWAIL): Theory, Methodology, or Both?”, International Community Law Review. Vol. 10, )2008(.
- De Lisle, Jacques de Lisle, “China’s Approach to International Law: A Historical Perspective”, American Society of International Law, Vol. 94, (2000).
- Dupuy, Pierre Marie, “Some Reflection on Contemporary International Law and the Appeal to Universal Values: A Response to Martti Koskenniemi”, The European Journal of International Law, 16, No. 1, (2005).
- Haji Yosefi, Amir Mohammad, Ghaebi, Reza, “The Concept of "Right to Development" in International Relations from the View of Post-Colonial Theory”, World Politics Quarterly, Volume 6, Issue 4, (2018). [In Persian]
- Kadkhodaei, Abbas Ali, Amirshekari, Amir Abbas, “An introduction to Koskenniemi’s Regressive Analysis in the structural study of international law”, Public Law Studies, Volume 45, Issue 3 - Serial Number 3, (2015). [In Persian]
- Koskenniemi, Martti, “The Fate of Public International Law: Between Technique and Politics”, The Modern Law Review, Vol. 70, No. 1, (2007).
- Lone, Fozia Nazir, “Edict in Pre-Colonial India: An Analysis from the New Haven Perspective”, Beijing Law Review, Vol. 5 No. 1, (2015).
- Lone, Fozia Nazir, “Cross-Fertilization of Westphalian Approaches to International: Third World Studies and a New Era of International Law Scholarship”, Emory International Law Review, Vol. 34, Issue 3, (2020).
- Ikenberry, G. John, “The Rise of China and the Future of the West: Can the Liberal System Survive?”, 87 Foreign AFF. 23, (2008).
- Jana, Benická, “Did its meaning change in Chinese philosophy? Some remarks on Fa in legalism and Confucianism”, Asian & African Studies. Vol. 10, (2001).
- Gu, Jing, Carty, Anthony, “China and African Development: Partnership Not Mentoring”, Institute Development Studies, Vol. 45, No. 4, (2014).
- Johns, Fleur, “Critical International Legal Theory”, UNSW Law, University of New South Wales Law Research Series (2018).
- Kennedy, David, “Primitive Legal Scholarship”, Harvard International Law Journal, Vol. 27, No. 1, (1986).
- Mohebi, Mohsen, “The third world, as an international legal system”, Legal Research Quarterly, Volume 1, Issue 9 - Serial Number 9, (1991). [In Persian]
- Murphy, Sean. D, “Deconstructing Fragmentation: Koskenniemi's 2006 ILC Project”, Temple International & Comparative Law Journal, No. 19, (2013).
- Mullerson, R, “Review of Martti Koskenniemi’s The Gentle Civilizer of Nations: The Rise and Fall of International law”, European Journal of International Law, Vol. 13, (2002).
- Mutua, Makau, “Critical Race Theory and international Law: The View of an Insider—Outsider”, University at Buffalo School of Law, Vol. 45, (2000).
- Neff, Stephen. C, “Justice among Nations: A History of International Law, Review by Jennifer Pitts, Political Theory”, Sage Publications, Vol. 43, No. 4, (2015).
- Opeoluwa Adetoro, Badaru, “Examining the Utility of Third World Approaches to International Law for International Human Rights Law”, International Law Community, Vol. 10, )2008(.
- Pan, Junwu, “Chinese Philosophy and International Law”, Asian Journal of International Law, Vol. 1, (2011).
- Pooja, Parmar, “TWAIL: An Epistemological Inquiry”, International Community Law Review, London, Vol. 10, No. 4, (2008).
- Ramezani Ghavam Abadi, Mohammad Hossein, Fateh, Omid, “Third World Critical Approach to International Law, With Emphasis on Human Rights Criticism”, Foreign Policy Quarterly, Volume 34, Issue 4, (2019). [In Persian]
- Ramina, Larissa, “TWAIL – “Third World Approaches to International Law” and Human Rights: some Considerations, Revista de Investigações Constitucionais”, Vol. 5, No. 1, (2019).
- Salimi, Hosein, Esmaeli Ardakani, Ali, “The Influence of Frankfurt School's Emancipatory Epistemology in International Relations Theory”, Foreign Affairs, Volume 6, Issue 3, (2013). [In Persian]
- Simbar, Reza, Bagheri, Arsalan, “Analyzing third Worldism in the International System”, Forein Realations Quarterly, Volume. 2, Issue. 8, (2009). [In Persian]
- Sornarajah, Muthucumaraswamy, Wang, Jiangyu, “China, India, and International Law: A Justic Based Vision Between the Romantic and Realist Perceptions”, Asian Journal of International Law, Vol. 9, (2019).
- Smith, Amber, “Third World Approaches to International Law: The Responsibility to Protect and Regional Organisations: An Overview”, Conference Paper, MPORIUM, issue 2, (2019).
- Thuo Gathii, James, “How American Support for Freedom of Commerce Legitimized King Leopold’s Territorial Ambitions in the Congo”, Loyola University Chicago School of Law, Vol. 37, (2005.(
- Thuo Gathii, James, “The Agenda of Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL)”, Cambridge University Press (2020).
- Thuo Gathii, James, “TWAIL: A Brief History of its Origins, its Decentralized Network and a Tentative Bibliography, Trade Law and Development”, Albany Law School Research Paper, Trade L. & DEV, Vol. 3, No. 35, )2011(.
- Thuo Gathii, James, “The Promise of International Law: A Third World View”, American University International Law Review, Vol. 36, No. 3, Article 1, (2021).
- Tzouvala, Ntina, “New Approaches to International Law: The History of a Project, European Journal of International Law”, Volume 27, Issue 1, (2016).
- Upendra, Baxi, “Too Many or Too Few, Human Rights?”, Human Rights Law Review, Vol. 1, No. 1, (2001).
- Rémi, Bachand, “Critical Approaches and the Third World. Towards a Global and Radical Critique of International Law”, Speech at University McGill, Vol. 1, (2010).
Instruments
- Jiabao, H.E. Wen, Premier of the State Council of the Peoples Republic of China, Statement at the General Debate of the 63rd Session of the U.N. General Assembly 3, (2008).
)